← All sources · 返回文献列表

18. Enhancing User Engagement: The Role of Gamification in Mobile Apps

提升用户投入:游戏化在移动应用中的作用 · Empirical survey study with a structural equation model (PLS-SEM) 实证问卷研究,采用结构方程模型(PLS-SEM) · Ch 6.2, 6.4, 7 · 30 min

Bitrián, P., Buil, I., & Catalán, S. (2021). Enhancing user engagement: The role of gamification in mobile apps. Journal of Business Research, 132, 170–185. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2021.04.028

The paper in 60 seconds · 60 秒读懂

Why we read it · 为什么要读

20-minute reading path · 20 分钟阅读路线

Pages 页码What to read读什么
170Abstract and the app usage figures (3 min).摘要和应用使用数据(3 分钟)。
174–175The three needs, the three element groups and Fig. 1 (5 min).三种需求、三类元素和图 1(5 分钟)。
176The 12 elements and the sample (3 min).12 个元素和样本(3 分钟)。
179–180Table 7, Table 8 and the autonomy explanation (6 min).表 7、表 8 和关于自主感的解释(6 分钟)。
181–182Practical implications and limits (3 min).实践启示与局限(3 分钟)。

1. Introduction · 1. 引言

Pages · 页码 170–171

2. Previous Research on Gamification and Engagement · 2. 游戏化与用户投入的已有研究

Pages · 页码 171–174

3.1 The Self-System Model of Motivational Development · 3.1 动机发展的自我系统模型

Pages · 页码 174

3.2 Research Model and Hypotheses · 3.2 研究模型与假设

Pages · 页码 174–175

4.1 Research Context: the Fitbit App · 4.1 研究情境:Fitbit 应用

Pages · 页码 175–176

4.2–4.4 Data, Measures and Common Method Bias · 4.2–4.4 数据、测量与共同方法偏差

Pages · 页码 176

5.1 Measurement Model · 5.1 测量模型

Pages · 页码 176–178

5.2 Structural Model · 5.2 结构模型

Pages · 页码 178–179

5.3 Post-hoc Analysis of Indirect Effects · 5.3 间接效应的事后分析

Pages · 页码 179–180

5.4 Endogeneity Testing · 5.4 内生性检验

Pages · 页码 180

6. Discussion · 6. 讨论

Pages · 页码 180–181

6.1 Theoretical Contributions · 6.1 理论贡献

Pages · 页码 181

6.2 Practical Implications · 6.2 实践启示

Pages · 页码 181–182

6.3 Limitations and Future Research · 6.3 局限与未来研究

Pages · 页码 182

Figures and tables · 图表解读

Exhibit 图表How to read it怎么看
Table 1 (pp. 172–173)Earlier studies grouped by type of engagement, with variables, design and findings. Look for the dark-side results, such as losing a contest.按投入类型整理的已有研究,列出变量、研究设计和发现。重点看负面效应,例如比赛失利。
Fig. 1 (p. 175)The proposed model: three element groups lead to three needs, then engagement, then three outcomes. Read left to right.研究模型:三类元素影响三种需求,再影响用户投入,最后影响三项结果。从左往右读。
Fig. 2 (p. 176)Screenshots of the Fitbit app tabs. Useful to picture what each game element looks like.Fitbit 应用各标签页截图。有助于直观了解每个游戏元素的样子。
Table 2 (p. 177)Means, loadings, AVE and reliability for each reflective scale. Relatedness has the lowest item means, from 4.36 to 4.76 out of 7.各反映型量表的均值、载荷、AVE 和信度。归属感题项的均值最低,在 7 分中为 4.36 到 4.76。
Table 6 (p. 179)Weights of each element inside its group. Competition dominates social elements; personalisation dominates immersion.每个元素在所属类别中的权重。竞争在社交类中占主导;个性化在沉浸类中占主导。
Table 7 (p. 179)Every hypothesis with β, t-value and whether supported. This is the key results table.每条假设的 β、t 值以及是否成立。这是最关键的结果表。
Table 8 (p. 180)Direct, indirect and total effects. Shows the negative total effect of social elements and full mediation for WOM.直接、间接和总效应。显示社交类元素的总效应为负,以及口碑的完全中介。

Key terms · 关键术语

Term 术语Meaning解释
gamification
游戏化
Adding game design elements to a non-game service.在非游戏服务中加入游戏设计元素。
SSMMD
动机发展的自我系统模型
A theory that people engage when settings meet their basic psychological needs.一种理论:当环境满足人的基本心理需求时,人就会投入。
competence
胜任感
Feeling capable of doing a task well.觉得自己能把任务做好。
autonomy
自主感
Feeling free to choose what to do.觉得可以自由选择做什么。
relatedness
归属感
Feeling connected to and cared for by others.觉得与他人有联系、被他人关心。
achievement and progression elements
成就与进度类元素
Scores, graphs, challenges, badges, progress bars and rankings.积分、表现图表、挑战、徽章、进度条和排名。
social elements
社交类元素
Competition, social networking features and cooperation.竞争、社交网络功能和合作。
immersion elements
沉浸类元素
Avatars or profiles, personalisation and virtual worlds.虚拟形象或个人资料、个性化和虚拟世界。
user engagement (UES-SF)
用户投入(UES-SF 量表)
Depth of a user's investment in a digital system, measured by aesthetic appeal, reward, focused attention and usability.用户在数字系统中投入的深度,用美感、回报感、专注度和易用性测量。
PLS-SEM
偏最小二乘结构方程模型
A regression-based method that tests many paths between constructs at once.一种基于回归的方法,可同时检验多个构念之间的路径。
mediation (full vs partial)
中介效应(完全与部分)
Full: the effect passes only through the middle variable. Partial: there is also a direct effect.完全中介:影响只通过中间变量传递。部分中介:同时还有直接影响。
endogeneity
内生性
Bias when a predictor is linked to unmeasured causes, which weakens causal claims.当预测变量与未测量的原因相关时产生的偏差,会削弱因果结论。

Numbers we can cite · 可引用的数字

Value 数值What it measures含义Page 页
276Final sample of U.S. Fitbit app users最终样本:276 名美国 Fitbit 应用用户p. 176
32%Users who open any one app more than 10 times打开同一应用超过 10 次的用户比例:32%p. 170
25%Apps used only once after download下载后只用一次的应用比例:25%p. 170
29.57 millionFitbit active users worldwide in 20192019 年 Fitbit 全球活跃用户 2,957 万(29.57 million)p. 175
12Game elements identified in the Fitbit appFitbit 应用中识别出的游戏元素:12 个p. 176
$0.70Payment per MTurk respondent每位 MTurk 受访者的报酬:$0.70p. 176
36Average age of respondents受访者平均年龄:36 岁p. 176
70.7%Variance in user engagement explained by the model模型解释的用户投入方差:70.7%p. 179
β = 0.646Achievement elements → competence成就类元素 → 胜任感:β = 0.646p. 179
β = 0.670Achievement elements → autonomy成就类元素 → 自主感:β = 0.670p. 179
β = −0.456Social elements → autonomy (negative, significant)社交类元素 → 自主感:β = −0.456(负向且显著)p. 179
β = 0.315Social elements → relatedness社交类元素 → 归属感:β = 0.315p. 179
β = 0.290Immersion elements → relatedness (their only significant path)沉浸类元素 → 归属感:β = 0.290(其唯一显著路径)p. 179
β = 0.435Competence → engagement胜任感 → 用户投入:β = 0.435p. 179
β = 0.425Autonomy → engagement自主感 → 用户投入:β = 0.425p. 179
β = 0.738Engagement → continued use intention用户投入 → 持续使用意愿:β = 0.738p. 179
β = 0.776Engagement → WOM intention用户投入 → 口碑意愿:β = 0.776p. 179
β = 0.585Engagement → app rating用户投入 → 应用评分:β = 0.585p. 179
β = −0.139Total effect of social elements on engagement社交类元素对用户投入的总效应:β = −0.139p. 179
5,000Bootstrap subsamples used to test paths用于检验路径的自助抽样次数:5,000p. 178

What it means for our report · 对报告的意义

Limits and where it does not fit · 局限与不适用之处

Questions for the group · 小组讨论问题

← Uniting the Tribes: Using Text for Marketing InsightDoes Gamification Affect Brand Engagement and Equity? A Study in Online Brand Communities →

Written by the group from the full text. Numbers and page references were checked against the source. Licensed cases and reports are summarised, not reproduced.
由小组根据全文整理,数字与页码已对照原文核对。授权案例与报告只作摘要,不转载原文。