← All sources · 返回文献列表

6. UI Dark Patterns and Where to Find Them: A Study on Mobile Applications and User Perception

UI 暗黑模式在哪里:一项关于移动应用与用户感知的研究 · Empirical HCI conference paper: expert coding of 240 Android apps (Study 1) plus an online video survey of 589 users (Study 2) 实证型人机交互(HCI)会议论文:专家对 240 款安卓应用编码(研究一),加上 589 名用户的在线视频问卷(研究二) · Ch 6.3, 6.4, 7, 8, 13 · 30 min

Di Geronimo, L., Braz, L., Fregnan, E., Palomba, F., & Bacchelli, A. (2020). UI dark patterns and where to find them: A study on mobile applications and user perception. In Proceedings of the 2020 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI '20) (pp. 1–14). ACM. https://doi.org/10.1145/3313831.3376600

The paper in 60 seconds · 60 秒读懂

Why we read it · 为什么要读

20-minute reading path · 20 分钟阅读路线

Pages 页码What to read读什么
3The five-type taxonomy and its subtypes.五大类分类法及其子类。
4The recording tasks and coding rules.录屏任务和编码规则。
5–6Table 1, the prevalence results and Figure 1.表 1、普遍性结果和图 1。
8–9DP-blindness results and Table 2.暗黑模式盲区结果和表 2。
10Implications and limitations.启示与局限。

Abstract and Introduction · 摘要与引言

Pages · 页码 1–2

Background: Ethical UX design and neuromarketing · 背景:伦理化 UX 设计与神经营销

Pages · 页码 2

Background: Taxonomies of dark patterns (Gray et al.) · 背景:暗黑模式分类法(Gray 等人)

Pages · 页码 2–3

Study 1: Corpus generation · 研究一:样本构建

Pages · 页码 3–4

Study 1: Recording and classification method · 研究一:录屏与编码方法

Pages · 页码 4

Study 1: Taxonomy adaptation and coding rules · 研究一:分类法调整与编码规则

Pages · 页码 4–5

Study 1: Results · 研究一:结果

Pages · 页码 5–6

Study 1: Discussion · 研究一:讨论

Pages · 页码 6

Study 2: Online experiment design · 研究二:在线实验设计

Pages · 页码 7

Study 2: Participants · 研究二:参与者

Pages · 页码 7–8

Study 2: Results on DP-blindness · 研究二:暗黑模式盲区结果

Pages · 页码 8–9

Study 2: Learnability and behaviour change · 研究二:学习效果与行为改变

Pages · 页码 9

Implications of the studies · 研究启示

Pages · 页码 9–10

Limitations · 局限

Pages · 页码 10

Conclusion and future work · 结论与未来工作

Pages · 页码 11

Figures and tables · 图表解读

Exhibit 图表How to read it怎么看
Table 1 (p. 5)Lists the 33 DP cases, each mapped to subclass codes and marked S (once per app) or M (many). Read it as the coding manual.列出 33 种暗黑模式情形,每种对应子类代码,并标注 S(每款应用只计一次)或 M(可多次)。可当作编码手册来读。
Figure 1 (p. 6)Bars show total DPs per subcategory; dots show the share of apps with each. Nagging, False Hierarchy and Preselection top the chart.柱形表示各子类的暗黑模式总数,点表示含该子类的应用比例。唠叨打断、虚假层级和预选位居前列。
Figure 2 (p. 6)A Daily Pixel rating popup that both interrupts the user and visually favours 5 stars.Daily Pixel 应用的评分弹窗,既打断用户,又在视觉上偏向 5 星。
Figure 3 (p. 7)Survey flow: intro, then two DP apps and one control app, each with familiarity, video, rating and 'malicious design?' steps, then screenshots and background.问卷流程:介绍后看两款含暗黑模式的应用和一款对照应用,每款都有熟悉度、视频、评分和「有无恶意设计」几步,最后看截图并填背景信息。
Figure 4 (p. 8)Screenshots of the five test DPs, such as Romwe's default insurance and Roblox's multiple currencies.五个测试用暗黑模式的截图,例如 Romwe 默认加购保险、Roblox 的多种货币。
Table 2 (p. 9)Per app: participants, and No / Not sure / Yes on spotting a malicious design. Romwe shows 34 Yes out of 248; Lego shows 510 No out of 589.按应用列出参与人数,以及是否发现恶意设计的「否/不确定/是」。Romwe 在 248 人中只有 34 人答「是」;Lego 在 589 人中有 510 人答「否」。
Table 3 (p. 9)Counts of how much learning about DPs would change downloading, use, rating and recommending. Some columns look garbled in the text extraction, so check the PDF.统计了解暗黑模式后,下载、使用、评分和推荐行为会改变多少。文字提取中部分列看起来错位,引用前请核对 PDF。

Key terms · 关键术语

Term 术语Meaning解释
Dark pattern (DP)
暗黑模式
An interface designed to trick users into actions they did not intend.故意诱导用户做出本不想做的操作的界面设计。
DP-blindness
暗黑模式盲区
Users failing to notice dark patterns, much like ignoring banner ads.用户对暗黑模式视而不见,类似对横幅广告的忽视。
Nagging
唠叨打断
Repeatedly pulling the user away from the task, often with popups.反复用弹窗等方式打断用户当前任务。
Intermediate Currency
中间货币
In-app tokens or gems that hide the real money cost.用应用内代币或宝石掩盖真实花费。
Roach Motel
蟑螂屋
Easy to get in, such as signing up, but hard to get out, such as deleting an account.进去容易(注册),出来难(删除账号)。
Sneak into Basket
偷加购物车
Adding unwanted items, such as insurance, to the cart by default.默认把保险等用户不要的商品加入购物车。
Preselection
预选
Options that favour the app are ticked by default.对应用有利的选项被默认勾选。
False Hierarchy
虚假层级
The app-friendly option is made bigger or brighter than the alternative.把对应用有利的选项做得更大、更醒目。
Toying with Emotions
玩弄情绪
Using emotion, such as countdowns on offers or shaming, to push a choice.用优惠倒计时、羞辱用户等情绪手段推动选择。
Forced Action
强制行动
Making users do a task, like watching an ad or logging in, to get something.要求用户完成某任务(如看广告、登录)才能获得好处。
Gamification (as a DP)
游戏化(作为暗黑模式)
Forcing dull repeated tasks to earn what could otherwise be bought.强迫用户重复枯燥任务,来换取本可用钱买到的东西。
Privacy Zuckering
隐私诱骗
Tricking users into sharing more personal data than they meant to.诱导用户分享超出本意的个人数据。

Numbers we can cite · 可引用的数字

Value 数值What it measures含义Page 页
240Trending free Android apps coded in Study 1研究 1(研究一)编码的热门免费安卓应用数量p. 3
2,400Minutes of recorded app use (ten minutes per app)录制的应用使用分钟数(每款十分钟)p. 4
120Hours spent on classification编码耗费的小时数p. 4
95%Share of apps with at least one dark pattern至少含一种暗黑模式的应用比例p. 5
1,787Total dark patterns found发现的暗黑模式总数p. 5
7.4Average dark patterns per app每款应用平均暗黑模式数p. 5
4.3Average subcategories per app out of 16每款应用平均涉及的子类数(共 16 个)p. 5
61%Apps with False Hierarchy含虚假层级的应用比例p. 5
60%Apps with Preselection含预选的应用比例p. 5
55%Apps that interrupted users (Nagging)会打断用户(唠叨打断)的应用比例p. 5
23DPs in Call Free, the worst app表现最差的 Call Free 所含暗黑模式数p. 5
31%Apps with Privacy Zuckering含隐私诱骗的应用比例p. 6
41%Apps with Roach Motel (no logout or no account deletion)含蟑螂屋(无法登出或删除账号)的应用比例p. 6
77%Shopping apps with Price Comparison Prevention含阻止比价的购物类应用比例p. 6
589Completed survey responses in Study 2研究 2(研究二)的完整问卷数p. 7
46Countries of survey participants问卷参与者来自的国家数p. 8
55%Answers on DP apps that saw no malicious design含暗黑模式应用中回答「没看到恶意设计」的比例p. 8
14%Detection rate for Romwe's pre-added insuranceRomwe 默认加购保险的识别率p. 8
86%Control answers correctly saying no DPs对照组中正确判断无暗黑模式的比例p. 8
24%Spotters whose answer matched the real DP自认发现者中答案与真实暗黑模式一致的比例p. 8
221.167Chi-square for detection differences across apps不同应用识别差异的卡方值p. 8
58.201Chi-square showing more attention after the first app显示看完第一款后更警觉的卡方值p. 9
32%Would change app downloading extremely or moderately会大幅或中度改变下载方式的比例p. 9
42%Acceptance of a paid plan under an aggressive DP in Luguri and StrahilevitzLuguri 与 Strahilevitz 研究中激进暗黑模式下接受付费计划的比例p. 2

What it means for our report · 对报告的意义

Limits and where it does not fit · 局限与不适用之处

Questions for the group · 小组讨论问题

← What's in the box? Investigating the benefits and risks of the blind box selling strategyLive streaming commerce and consumers' purchase intention: An uncertainty reduction perspective →

Written by the group from the full text. Numbers and page references were checked against the source. Licensed cases and reports are summarised, not reproduced.
由小组根据全文整理,数字与页码已对照原文核对。授权案例与报告只作摘要,不转载原文。