← All sources · 返回文献列表

20. Resale or agency sale? Equilibrium analysis on the role of live streaming selling

自营转售还是平台代销?直播带货作用的均衡分析 · Analytical journal article (game-theory supply-chain model with numerical examples; no survey or sales data) 分析型期刊论文(博弈论供应链模型 + 数值算例;没有问卷或销售数据) · Ch 4, 5, 10, 11 · 35 min

Hao, C., & Yang, L. (2023). Resale or agency sale? Equilibrium analysis on the role of live streaming selling. European Journal of Operational Research, 307, 1117–1134. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2022.09.021

The paper in 60 seconds · 60 秒读懂

Why we read it · 为什么要读

20-minute reading path · 20 分钟阅读路线

Pages 页码What to read读什么
1117–1118Read the abstract and introduction for the three strategies and the main findings.先读摘要和引言,了解三种策略和主要结论。
1119–1120Skim the assumptions and Table 1 so the symbols make sense.浏览假设和表 1,弄清各个符号。
1122, 1124Read Theorem 1, Proposition 1 and Proposition 3 with Figs. 2 and 5.结合图 2 和图 5,阅读定理 1、命题 1 和命题 3。
1127–1128Read Proposition 4 for when resale becomes the shared choice.阅读命题 4,了解转售何时成为双方共同选择。
1132–1133Finish with the conclusions and managerial implications.最后阅读结论和管理启示。

Abstract · 摘要

Pages · 页码 1117

1. Introduction · 1. 引言

Pages · 页码 1117–1118

2. Literature review (2.1–2.3) · 2. 文献综述(2.1–2.3)

Pages · 页码 1118–1119

3.1 Model set-up and assumptions · 3.1 模型设定与假设

Pages · 页码 1119–1120

3.2 Optimal decisions · 3.2 最优决策

Pages · 页码 1120–1121

3.3 Choice of sales format (no returns) · 3.3 销售模式选择(不考虑退货)

Pages · 页码 1121–1123

3.4 Choice of pricing strategy (no returns) · 3.4 定价策略选择(不考虑退货)

Pages · 页码 1123–1124

4.1 Adding consumer returns · 4.1 加入消费者退货

Pages · 页码 1124–1125

4.2 Returns and the choice of sales format · 4.2 退货对销售模式选择的影响

Pages · 页码 1125–1128

4.3 Returns and the choice of pricing strategy · 4.3 退货对定价策略选择的影响

Pages · 页码 1128–1129

5. Hybrid sales format (5.1–5.2) · 5. 混合销售模式(5.1–5.2)

Pages · 页码 1129–1131

6. Extensions (6.1–6.3) · 6. 模型扩展(6.1–6.3)

Pages · 页码 1131–1132

7. Conclusions, managerial implications and limitations · 7. 结论、管理启示与局限

Pages · 页码 1132–1133

Figures and tables · 图表解读

Exhibit 图表How to read it怎么看
Fig. 1 (p. 1119)Two channel diagrams. In R, goods flow supplier to platform to buyers; in A, the supplier sells to buyers and pays the platform.两张渠道结构图。R 模式下货品从供应商到平台再到买家;A 模式下供应商直接卖给买家,并向平台付佣。
Table 1 (p. 1120)The notation list. Keep it open while reading: θ is commission, m is live-stream cost, l is low-value buyers' valuation, α is return rate.符号表。阅读时建议对照:θ 是佣金率,m 是直播成本系数,l 是低估值买家估值,α 是退货率。
Table 2 (p. 1121)Optimal live-stream effort and wholesale price for each strategy and format, with the conditions under which each holds.各策略、各模式下的最优直播投入和批发价,以及各自成立的条件。
Fig. 2 (p. 1122)Equilibrium map for HH without returns. Region II is where both firms prefer A; no region has both preferring R.不考虑退货时 HH 策略的均衡图。区域 II 是双方都偏好 A;没有任何区域双方都偏好 R。
Fig. 3 (p. 1123)Platform's profit gap between R and A as live-stream cost rises, at θ = 0.4 and l = 0.6. Above zero means R is better.在 θ = 0.4、l = 0.6 时,随直播成本上升,平台在 R 与 A 之间的利润差。高于零表示 R 更好。
Fig. 4 (p. 1123)Equilibrium region for A under D, at l = 0.9 and θ = 0.15. The shaded area is where both firms prefer A.在 l = 0.9、θ = 0.15 时,D 策略下 A 模式的均衡区域。阴影部分是双方都偏好 A 的范围。
Fig. 5 (p. 1124)Best pricing strategy in A. Region I: both pick HH. Region III: both pick LL. Region II: they disagree.A 模式下的最优定价策略。区域 I 双方都选 HH;区域 III 双方都选 LL;区域 II 双方意见不一。
Table 4 and Fig. 6 (p. 1126)Profit gaps (R minus A) under HH with returns. Negative for the supplier means it prefers A. Fig. 6 shows the switch at a return rate of 0.06.考虑退货后 HH 策略下的利润差(R 减 A)。供应商的值为负表示它偏好 A。图 6 展示退货率为 0.06 时的转换。
Fig. 7 and Table 5 (pp. 1127–1128)Profit gaps under D with returns, by valuation and commission. They show when supplier and platform disagree.考虑退货后 D 策略下的利润差,按估值和佣金分组,显示双方何时意见相左。
Fig. 8 (p. 1128)Resale equilibrium under D at l = 0.7, α = 0.4, θ = 0.4. The overlap is where both firms gain from R.在 l = 0.7、α = 0.4、θ = 0.4 时 D 策略下的转售均衡。重叠部分是双方都从 R 获益的范围。
Fig. 9, Tables 6–7 (p. 1129)Best pricing strategy by format once returns rise. Read across: higher returns shift the supplier toward LL.退货上升后各模式下的最优定价策略。横向看:退货越高,供应商越转向 LL。
Fig. 10 and Fig. 11 (pp. 1129–1131)Fig. 10 shows the hybrid channel layout. Fig. 11 shows where the hybrid beats pure R or pure A under D.图 10 展示混合模式的渠道结构。图 11 显示 D 策略下混合模式何时优于纯 R 或纯 A。

Key terms · 关键术语

Term 术语Meaning解释
resale format (R)
转售模式(自营)
The platform buys stock from the brand and sells it itself. Not secondhand resale.平台向品牌进货后自己销售,即自营;不是二手转卖。
agency sale format (A)
代销模式(平台入驻)
The brand sells on the platform and pays it a share of revenue as commission.品牌在平台上开店直接卖货,并按收入比例向平台交佣金。
hybrid format (RA)
混合模式
The platform resells some stock and also hosts the brand's own store.平台一边自营部分货品,一边开放品牌自己的店铺。
double marginalization
双重加价
Each firm in the chain adds its own markup, so the final price is higher and sales are lower.供应链上每家企业各自加价,导致终端价格更高、销量更低。
strategy HH (same high)
同高价策略
The same high price in the live stream and the regular page, with strict price control.直播间与普通页同样高价,严格控价。
strategy D (differential)
差别定价策略
A lower price only in the live stream, a higher price on the regular page.只在直播间降价,普通页保持高价。
strategy LL (same low)
同低价策略
The same low price in both channels, serving all buyers.两个渠道同样低价,服务所有买家。
equilibrium format
均衡模式
A sales format that both the brand and the platform prefer, so the deal can happen.品牌和平台都偏好的销售模式,因此交易能够达成。
seller live streaming
商家自播
Live streams run often by store staff, rather than by a celebrity host.由店铺员工经常性开播的直播,而不是请明星或达人主播。
quality mismatch
质量错配
When the product does not meet the buyer's expectations, which leads to a return.商品达不到买家预期,从而导致退货。
commission rate
佣金率
The share of sales revenue the brand pays the platform in agency sale.代销模式下品牌按销售收入付给平台的比例。
Hotelling line
霍特林线
A simple way to model shoppers who prefer one channel over another, besides price.一种建模方法,用来表示消费者除价格外对某个渠道的偏好。

Numbers we can cite · 可引用的数字

Value 数值What it measures含义Page 页
635 millionLive-stream users in China by end-2021.截至 2021 年底中国直播用户数(6.35 亿)。p. 1117
61.5%Share of Chinese internet users who use live streams.中国网民中直播用户的占比。p. 1117
464 millionE-commerce live-stream users in China.中国电商直播用户数(4.64 亿)。p. 1117
64%Agency sale share of Amazon's total sales in 2021.2021 年亚马逊总销售中代销的占比。p. 1117
20.8%Average US online return rate in 2021.2021 年美国网购平均退货率。p. 1117
30%Return rate for top Chinese live streamers.中国头部主播的退货率。p. 1117
70%Return rate for other Chinese streamers, at the high end.中国其他主播退货率的高端水平。p. 1117
60%Live-stream return rate during Double 11 in 2021.2021 年「双十一」(Double 11)期间直播退货率。p. 1117
55%Seller live-stream rooms as a share of Taobao live rooms in 2020.2020 年商家自播间占淘宝直播间的比例。p. 1118
9 timesKuaishou seller live-stream sales in Q4 2021 versus Q1.2021 年 Q4(第四季度)快手商家自播销量是 Q1(第一季度)的倍数。p. 1118
6% to 25%Amazon commission range by product category.亚马逊按品类的佣金范围。p. 1119
5% to 12%JD.com commission range.京东的佣金范围。p. 1119
20-50%Typical commission on services, higher than on goods.服务类佣金的常见范围,高于实物商品。p. 1119
θ = 0.4, l = 0.6Parameter values used for Fig. 3.图 3 使用的参数值。p. 1122
l = 0.9, θ = 0.15Parameter values used for Fig. 4.图 4 使用的参数值。p. 1123
α = 0.06Medium return rate at which the supplier's switch appears in Fig. 6.图 6 中出现供应商模式转换的中等退货率。p. 1126
0.93Lower bound of a narrow valuation interval the authors set aside under D.D 策略下作者略过的狭窄估值区间的下限。p. 1126
l = 0.7, α = 0.4, θ = 0.4Parameter values used for Fig. 8.图 8 使用的参数值。p. 1128
0.05Commission threshold below which the platform may prefer pure resale under HH.HH 策略下平台可能偏好纯转售的佣金门槛。p. 1130

What it means for our report · 对报告的意义

Limits and where it does not fit · 局限与不适用之处

Questions for the group · 小组讨论问题

← Does Gamification Affect Brand Engagement and Equity? A Study in Online Brand CommunitiesConsumer Engagement in Social Media Brand Communities: A Literature Review →

Written by the group from the full text. Numbers and page references were checked against the source. Licensed cases and reports are summarised, not reproduced.
由小组根据全文整理,数字与页码已对照原文核对。授权案例与报告只作摘要,不转载原文。