社交媒体品牌社群中的消费者参与:文献综述 · Systematic (descriptive) literature review of 134 journal articles, ending in 10 propositions and an integrative framework 系统性(描述型)文献综述,分析 134 篇期刊论文,最后提出 10 条命题和一个整合框架 · Ch 4, 5, 7, 8, 9 · 30 min
Santos, Z. R., Cheung, C. M. K., Coelho, P. S., & Rita, P. (2022). Consumer engagement in social media brand communities: A literature review. International Journal of Information Management, 63, Article 102457. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2021.102457
| Pages 页码 | What to read | 读什么 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Read the abstract for the scope and main claims. | 读摘要,了解范围和主要结论。 |
| 4–6 | Skim Fig. 1 and Table 3 for the sample and method mix. | 浏览图 1 和表 3,了解样本和方法构成。 |
| 7, 12 | Read Table 4 and Table 10 for the three definitions side by side. | 读表 4 和表 10,对比三种定义。 |
| 12–14 | Read sections 5.2 to 5.5 and Fig. 3, the core of the paper. | 读 5.2 至 5.5 节和图 3,这是全文核心。 |
| 15–16 | Read the practical implications in section 5.8. | 读 5.8 节的实践意义。 |
Pages · 页码 1–2
Pages · 页码 2–5
Pages · 页码 5–7
Pages · 页码 7–11
Pages · 页码 11–12
Pages · 页码 12–14
Pages · 页码 14
Pages · 页码 14–15
Pages · 页码 15–16
| Exhibit 图表 | How to read it | 怎么看 |
|---|---|---|
| Table 1 (p. 3) | Lists 12 earlier review studies with concept, focus, context and objective. Read it to see the gap: none targets engagement with the community itself. | 列出 12 篇以往综述的概念、对象、情境和目的。读它可看到研究空白:没有一篇针对对社群本身的参与。 |
| Fig. 1 (p. 4) | Flow chart of the search: database and manual search give 371 studies, 121 are excluded, and 134 remain. | 检索流程图:数据库与人工检索得到 371 篇,剔除 121 篇,剩下 134 篇。 |
| Table 2 (p. 5) | Counts initial and eligible articles per top journal. Computers in Human Behavior gives the most, 11 eligible. | 按顶级期刊统计初始和合格论文数。Computers in Human Behavior 最多,合格 11 篇。 |
| Table 3 (p. 6) | Papers by type and year. Read the bottom row for growth, and the right column for the mix: survey 56%, content analysis 15%. | 按类型和年份统计的论文数。看底行了解增长趋势,看右列了解构成:问卷占 56%,内容分析占 15%。 |
| Table 4 (p. 7) | The three definition approaches (motivation, attitude, behaviour), each with its source definition and the studies that adopted it. | 三种定义取向(动机、态度、行为),各附原始定义和采用该定义的研究。 |
| Tables 5–8 (pp. 8–10) | Engagement as cause, outcome, mediator and moderator. Each row lists the linked variables and how engagement was measured. | 参与分别作为原因、结果、中介和调节变量。每行列出相关变量和参与的测量方式。 |
| Table 9 (p. 10) | Content-analysis studies, split by whether engagement behaviour is a cause or a consequence. | 内容分析研究,按参与行为是原因还是结果来划分。 |
| Fig. 2 (p. 11) | Classification framework grouping variables into social, personal, mass-communication, brand-related and community-related factors. | 分类框架,把变量归入社会、个人、大众传播、品牌相关和社群相关因素。 |
| Table 10 (p. 12) | Side-by-side summary of the attitudinal (33 articles), motivational (17) and behavioural (24) approaches: dimensions, variables, theories, contexts. | 并列总结态度取向(33 篇)、动机取向(17 篇)和行为取向(24 篇):维度、变量、理论和情境。 |
| Fig. 3 (p. 13) | The integrative framework. Read left to right: antecedents, engagement, consequences, with mediators and moderators marked on the arrows. | 整合框架。从左到右读:前因、参与、后果,箭头上标出中介和调节变量。 |
| Term 术语 | Meaning | 解释 |
|---|---|---|
| consumer engagement in a social media brand community 社交媒体品牌社群中的消费者参与 | How much, and in what way, a consumer chooses to interact with a brand's online community. | 消费者愿意与品牌线上社群互动的程度和方式。 |
| motivational approach 动机取向 | Defines engagement as the inner drive to interact and cooperate with community members. | 把参与定义为与社群成员互动、合作的内在驱动力。 |
| attitudinal approach 态度取向 | Defines engagement as a state of mind with cognitive, emotional and behavioural parts. | 把参与定义为包含认知、情感和行为成分的心理状态。 |
| behavioural approach 行为取向 | Defines engagement as visible actions, such as posts, likes, comments and shares. | 把参与定义为可见的行为,如发帖、点赞、评论和分享。 |
| Uses and Gratifications Theory (UGT) 使用与满足理论 | People choose a medium for the benefits they expect from it. | 人们根据预期获得的好处来选择媒介。 |
| Social Identity Theory (SIT) 社会认同理论 | People take part of their identity from groups they value, so they engage to belong. | 人们从所看重的群体中获得部分身份认同,因此为归属而参与。 |
| relationship marketing 关系营销 | Marketing that aims at long, close relationships with customers, not single sales. | 以与顾客建立长期密切关系为目标,而非单次交易的营销方式。 |
| antecedent 前因 | A factor that comes before engagement and drives it. | 发生在参与之前、驱动参与的因素。 |
| mediator 中介变量 | A variable that carries the effect from one factor to another. | 把一个因素的影响传递给另一个因素的变量。 |
| moderator 调节变量 | A variable that makes a link stronger or weaker. | 使某种关系变强或变弱的变量。 |
| lurker 潜水者 | A member who reads community content but rarely posts or reacts. | 浏览社群内容但很少发帖或互动的成员。 |
| netnography 网络民族志 | Qualitative study of online communities by observing what members post and do. | 通过观察成员的发帖和行为来研究线上社群的定性方法。 |
| value co-destruction 价值共毁 | Negative interactions between consumers and brands that destroy value instead of creating it. | 消费者与品牌之间的负面互动,毁掉而不是创造价值。 |
| Value 数值 | What it measures | 含义 | Page 页 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 134 | Articles in the final review sample | 最终纳入综述的论文数 | p. 1 |
| six steps | Steps in the Templier and Paré review process (6) | Templier 与 Paré 综述流程的步骤数(6) | p. 3 |
| RQ7 | Seven research questions guided the review (RQ1–RQ7) | 指导综述的 7 个研究问题(RQ1–RQ7) | p. 3 |
| ten top | Journals hand-searched in the manual stage (10) | 人工检索阶段查阅的顶级期刊数(10) | p. 3 |
| seventy-one primary studies | Primary studies matching the topic after removing duplicates (371, written as three-hundred and seventy-one) | 去重后符合主题的原始研究数(371 篇,原文以英文单词写出) | p. 4 |
| 121 | Articles excluded as special-case communities | 因属于特殊类型社群而剔除的论文数 | p. 4 |
| 65 | Final papers that came from the ten top journals | 来自 10 本顶级期刊的最终论文数 | p. 5 |
| 49% | Share of final papers from the ten top journals | 最终论文中来自 10 本顶级期刊的比例 | p. 5 |
| 70% | Papers using quantitative methods (more than 70%) | 使用定量方法的论文比例(超过 70%) | p. 5 |
| 56% | Papers using survey research | 使用问卷调查的论文比例 | p. 5 |
| 15% | Papers using quantitative content analysis | 使用定量内容分析的论文比例 | p. 5 |
| 2005 | Year of the oldest included study (Algesheimer et al.) | 纳入的最早研究的年份(Algesheimer 等人) | p. 5 |
| 2011 | Year when papers on the topic began to appear | 该主题论文开始出现的年份 | p. 5 |
| 75 | Survey-research papers in the sample | 样本中问卷调查类论文数 | p. 6 |
| 27 | Papers published in 2017, the peak year | 2017 年发表的论文数(最高峰) | p. 6 |
| 9% | Share of qualitative-research papers (12 papers) | 定性研究论文占比(12 篇) | p. 6 |
| 33 | Articles using the attitudinal approach | 采用态度取向的论文数 | p. 12 |
| 17 | Articles using the motivational approach | 采用动机取向的论文数 | p. 12 |
| 24 | Articles using the behavioural approach | 采用行为取向的论文数 | p. 12 |
| Proposition 10 | Number of propositions in the framework (10) | 框架中的命题数(10) | p. 14 |
Written by the group from the full text. Numbers and page references were checked against the source. Licensed cases and reports are summarised, not reproduced.
由小组根据全文整理,数字与页码已对照原文核对。授权案例与报告只作摘要,不转载原文。