← All sources · 返回文献列表

21. Consumer Engagement in Social Media Brand Communities: A Literature Review

社交媒体品牌社群中的消费者参与:文献综述 · Systematic (descriptive) literature review of 134 journal articles, ending in 10 propositions and an integrative framework 系统性(描述型)文献综述,分析 134 篇期刊论文,最后提出 10 条命题和一个整合框架 · Ch 4, 5, 7, 8, 9 · 30 min

Santos, Z. R., Cheung, C. M. K., Coelho, P. S., & Rita, P. (2022). Consumer engagement in social media brand communities: A literature review. International Journal of Information Management, 63, Article 102457. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2021.102457

The paper in 60 seconds · 60 秒读懂

Why we read it · 为什么要读

20-minute reading path · 20 分钟阅读路线

Pages 页码What to read读什么
1Read the abstract for the scope and main claims.读摘要,了解范围和主要结论。
4–6Skim Fig. 1 and Table 3 for the sample and method mix.浏览图 1 和表 3,了解样本和方法构成。
7, 12Read Table 4 and Table 10 for the three definitions side by side.读表 4 和表 10,对比三种定义。
12–14Read sections 5.2 to 5.5 and Fig. 3, the core of the paper.读 5.2 至 5.5 节和图 3,这是全文核心。
15–16Read the practical implications in section 5.8.读 5.8 节的实践意义。

1–2. Introduction and concepts · 1–2. 引言与概念

Pages · 页码 1–2

3. Method · 3. 研究方法

Pages · 页码 2–5

4.1 Results: types of study · 4.1 结果:研究类型

Pages · 页码 5–7

4.2 Results: domain, model roles and theories · 4.2 结果:定义、模型角色与理论

Pages · 页码 7–11

5.1 Discussion: conceptualisation · 5.1 讨论:概念界定

Pages · 页码 11–12

5.2–5.3 Antecedents and consequences (Propositions 1–7) · 5.2–5.3 前因与后果(命题 1–7)

Pages · 页码 12–14

5.4–5.6 Mediators, moderators and the integrative framework (Propositions 8–10) · 5.4–5.6 中介、调节与整合框架(命题 8–10)

Pages · 页码 14

5.7 Future research directions · 5.7 未来研究方向

Pages · 页码 14–15

5.8–6 Practical implications, limitations and conclusion · 5.8–6 实践意义、局限与结论

Pages · 页码 15–16

Figures and tables · 图表解读

Exhibit 图表How to read it怎么看
Table 1 (p. 3)Lists 12 earlier review studies with concept, focus, context and objective. Read it to see the gap: none targets engagement with the community itself.列出 12 篇以往综述的概念、对象、情境和目的。读它可看到研究空白:没有一篇针对对社群本身的参与。
Fig. 1 (p. 4)Flow chart of the search: database and manual search give 371 studies, 121 are excluded, and 134 remain.检索流程图:数据库与人工检索得到 371 篇,剔除 121 篇,剩下 134 篇。
Table 2 (p. 5)Counts initial and eligible articles per top journal. Computers in Human Behavior gives the most, 11 eligible.按顶级期刊统计初始和合格论文数。Computers in Human Behavior 最多,合格 11 篇。
Table 3 (p. 6)Papers by type and year. Read the bottom row for growth, and the right column for the mix: survey 56%, content analysis 15%.按类型和年份统计的论文数。看底行了解增长趋势,看右列了解构成:问卷占 56%,内容分析占 15%。
Table 4 (p. 7)The three definition approaches (motivation, attitude, behaviour), each with its source definition and the studies that adopted it.三种定义取向(动机、态度、行为),各附原始定义和采用该定义的研究。
Tables 5–8 (pp. 8–10)Engagement as cause, outcome, mediator and moderator. Each row lists the linked variables and how engagement was measured.参与分别作为原因、结果、中介和调节变量。每行列出相关变量和参与的测量方式。
Table 9 (p. 10)Content-analysis studies, split by whether engagement behaviour is a cause or a consequence.内容分析研究,按参与行为是原因还是结果来划分。
Fig. 2 (p. 11)Classification framework grouping variables into social, personal, mass-communication, brand-related and community-related factors.分类框架,把变量归入社会、个人、大众传播、品牌相关和社群相关因素。
Table 10 (p. 12)Side-by-side summary of the attitudinal (33 articles), motivational (17) and behavioural (24) approaches: dimensions, variables, theories, contexts.并列总结态度取向(33 篇)、动机取向(17 篇)和行为取向(24 篇):维度、变量、理论和情境。
Fig. 3 (p. 13)The integrative framework. Read left to right: antecedents, engagement, consequences, with mediators and moderators marked on the arrows.整合框架。从左到右读:前因、参与、后果,箭头上标出中介和调节变量。

Key terms · 关键术语

Term 术语Meaning解释
consumer engagement in a social media brand community
社交媒体品牌社群中的消费者参与
How much, and in what way, a consumer chooses to interact with a brand's online community.消费者愿意与品牌线上社群互动的程度和方式。
motivational approach
动机取向
Defines engagement as the inner drive to interact and cooperate with community members.把参与定义为与社群成员互动、合作的内在驱动力。
attitudinal approach
态度取向
Defines engagement as a state of mind with cognitive, emotional and behavioural parts.把参与定义为包含认知、情感和行为成分的心理状态。
behavioural approach
行为取向
Defines engagement as visible actions, such as posts, likes, comments and shares.把参与定义为可见的行为,如发帖、点赞、评论和分享。
Uses and Gratifications Theory (UGT)
使用与满足理论
People choose a medium for the benefits they expect from it.人们根据预期获得的好处来选择媒介。
Social Identity Theory (SIT)
社会认同理论
People take part of their identity from groups they value, so they engage to belong.人们从所看重的群体中获得部分身份认同,因此为归属而参与。
relationship marketing
关系营销
Marketing that aims at long, close relationships with customers, not single sales.以与顾客建立长期密切关系为目标,而非单次交易的营销方式。
antecedent
前因
A factor that comes before engagement and drives it.发生在参与之前、驱动参与的因素。
mediator
中介变量
A variable that carries the effect from one factor to another.把一个因素的影响传递给另一个因素的变量。
moderator
调节变量
A variable that makes a link stronger or weaker.使某种关系变强或变弱的变量。
lurker
潜水者
A member who reads community content but rarely posts or reacts.浏览社群内容但很少发帖或互动的成员。
netnography
网络民族志
Qualitative study of online communities by observing what members post and do.通过观察成员的发帖和行为来研究线上社群的定性方法。
value co-destruction
价值共毁
Negative interactions between consumers and brands that destroy value instead of creating it.消费者与品牌之间的负面互动,毁掉而不是创造价值。

Numbers we can cite · 可引用的数字

Value 数值What it measures含义Page 页
134Articles in the final review sample最终纳入综述的论文数p. 1
six stepsSteps in the Templier and Paré review process (6)Templier 与 Paré 综述流程的步骤数(6)p. 3
RQ7Seven research questions guided the review (RQ1–RQ7)指导综述的 7 个研究问题(RQ1–RQ7)p. 3
ten topJournals hand-searched in the manual stage (10)人工检索阶段查阅的顶级期刊数(10)p. 3
seventy-one primary studiesPrimary studies matching the topic after removing duplicates (371, written as three-hundred and seventy-one)去重后符合主题的原始研究数(371 篇,原文以英文单词写出)p. 4
121Articles excluded as special-case communities因属于特殊类型社群而剔除的论文数p. 4
65Final papers that came from the ten top journals来自 10 本顶级期刊的最终论文数p. 5
49%Share of final papers from the ten top journals最终论文中来自 10 本顶级期刊的比例p. 5
70%Papers using quantitative methods (more than 70%)使用定量方法的论文比例(超过 70%)p. 5
56%Papers using survey research使用问卷调查的论文比例p. 5
15%Papers using quantitative content analysis使用定量内容分析的论文比例p. 5
2005Year of the oldest included study (Algesheimer et al.)纳入的最早研究的年份(Algesheimer 等人)p. 5
2011Year when papers on the topic began to appear该主题论文开始出现的年份p. 5
75Survey-research papers in the sample样本中问卷调查类论文数p. 6
27Papers published in 2017, the peak year2017 年发表的论文数(最高峰)p. 6
9%Share of qualitative-research papers (12 papers)定性研究论文占比(12 篇)p. 6
33Articles using the attitudinal approach采用态度取向的论文数p. 12
17Articles using the motivational approach采用动机取向的论文数p. 12
24Articles using the behavioural approach采用行为取向的论文数p. 12
Proposition 10Number of propositions in the framework (10)框架中的命题数(10)p. 14

What it means for our report · 对报告的意义

Limits and where it does not fit · 局限与不适用之处

Questions for the group · 小组讨论问题

← Resale or agency sale? Equilibrium analysis on the role of live streaming sellingImpact of Product Characteristics of Limited Edition Shoes on Perceived Value, Brand Trust, and Purchase Intention; Focused on the Scarcity Message Frequency →

Written by the group from the full text. Numbers and page references were checked against the source. Licensed cases and reports are summarised, not reproduced.
由小组根据全文整理,数字与页码已对照原文核对。授权案例与报告只作摘要,不转载原文。